I have included abook review for illustration purposes. In my first attempt to do a criticalbook review I examined a number of critical book reviews in history in searchofthe common elements. Examining thework of others can provide invaluable information. I would recommend that youread a number of book reviews if you are uncomfortable about writing. I thinkthe following book review is a good example of a critical book review inhistory. The entire review is less than two pages, approximately 650 words,that also fits the criteria for most upper level assignments.
The next question is answered by looking at the theme of the work towards ascertaining what the author was attempting to do or achieve with the book. Look at the author's arguments and assumptions and see whether these arguments are supported with enough evidence and proper documentation. You should also look out for contradictions in the work and point them out. State if the conclusion of the author is convincing enough. The next part of our critical book review example takes care of the contributions by the author. This is where you will see if the book has something new on offer. If yes, then look for the new evidence given and check if new issues and some other unanswered questions were raised.
Critical Book Review Example and Tutorial | Daily Mayo
Most authors are great researchers, but quite often they are overcommitted. That is why they could seem absent-minded to a person who writes a critical book review, and not infrequently many of them fail to put good care into the chapter. Alternatively, the writer may decide to hand off the work to a colleague or graduate student and thus become a second author. To avoid such changeovers editors often specify the requirements for the invited author and establish strict responsibility so that the author could not pass the work to any student in exchange for a . Nevertheless, if the chapter is badly written, the reviewer must simply forbid its publication. As it often happens, the chapter may appear so messy, that the author should express gratitude to you for avoiding embarrassment. In that case, the editor proposes to the writer another chance with a demand for a thorough revision and another critical book review. Usually, no one chooses to reject the author for the first time, and many of them pay back with eager labor for the understanding and grace. In this way, many initially bad drafts are eventually published, although the editor and reviewer may make an enormous effort to shape it into a publishable form.